Narrative practices offer a different way to look at school failure: instead of treating a struggling child as the problem, they separate the person from the problem and help the child tell a new story. The approach rests on a simple idea: every human being tells stories that shape identity, and the events of a life, along with what others say about us, supply the raw material for those stories.
A story links events along the axis of time and highlights a theme. Sometimes one version of a life becomes dominant and starts to limit freedom, wellbeing or growth. As Boris Cyrulnik put it, what we tell ourselves about what happens to us is more decisive than what happens to us.
Quick takeaways
- The person is not the problem: separate the child from the difficulty
- Listen to the complaint before looking for solutions
- Hunt for exceptions where the problem did not take over
- Let friends name qualities the child cannot yet see
- Link small moments into a richer alternative story
- Bring in outside witnesses to confirm the new story
Dominant Stories and Alternative Stories
Narrative practices distinguish the dominant story from the alternative story. The dominant story is the one that structures a person's life so strongly that it reduces freedom and can keep someone from thriving or moving forward. The alternative story is the one the narrative approach helps bring to the surface.
The method invites people to look for exceptions to their dominant story and to build a meaningful, liberating alternative from them. For a child who struggles at school, the dominant story often forms around suffering or a problem. Narrative practices hold that the person is the person, the problem is the problem, and the person is not the problem.
Listening to the complaint first
Listening with empathy to what a young person complains about, and to the effect it has on the image they hold of themselves, is where the work begins. From that complaint, the problem story can emerge and be separated from the child. A calm, patient ear matters more here than any quick fix.

Making Hidden Skills Visible
Dina Scherrer, a coach trained in narrative practices who works in middle and high schools with young people facing academic and relational difficulties, sees the approach as especially relevant for students in school failure. It helps them restore their self-image and recover hope in the future.
To help them weave a new story, she helps them make visible all the skills they have built without noticing. She invites them to hunt for every exception, every time the problem did not catch, smother or paralyse them, and to link those moments like the episodes of a new story. The richer this new story becomes, the less influence the problem story has on the person and on their behaviour.
This is close to what happens when a child discovers a passion through imaginative play or gains confidence through Montessori toys, where competence grows quietly before anyone names it. It also echoes how children get more car sick when young, a hidden sensitivity adults often overlook. Even playful stories like pregnant Disney princesses show how a familiar narrative can be rewritten.

| Narrative tool | What it does | How a parent can use it |
|---|---|---|
| Listening to the complaint | Names the problem without blaming the child | Ask what school feels like, without correcting |
| Searching for exceptions | Finds moments the problem was absent | Ask about a day that went better and why |
| Friendship pair exercise | Lets a peer name the child's strengths | Invite a friend over and ask what they like |
| Guiding questions | Helps the child own the qualities | Ask what a friend would say about them |
| Outside witnesses | Confirms and strengthens the new story | Share the child's progress with people who matter |
Seeing Yourself Through the Eyes of Friendship
Many young people find it hard to identify and say their strengths out loud. One exercise pairs each student with a close friend: taking turns, one speaks about the other and about the reasons they are friends, while the listener stays silent and may speak at the end if they wish. A kind, neutral adult can be present.
The goal is for each child to see themselves through the eyes of friendship and regain confidence. Guiding questions help: Why did you choose to be together for this pair? What connects you two? What do you like about them? What do they do well that you envy? What do you think they like about you? Can you tell a story that illustrates it? Kids can also record these reflections in primary school notebooks.
Helping the child take it in
Afterwards, the adult can invite the listener to rephrase what they heard: What does it feel like to hear your friend say that about you? What does it say about you? What did you learn about yourself and about what matters to you? Who close to you would not be surprised that you have these skills, and where do you get them from? Can you tell a story showing you do this so well?
The exercise deliberately looks for the people in a child's history who would not be surprised by their inner treasure, so that qualities spoken by a third party can be heard and consciously owned as part of their personality. For children who admire superhero toys, framing strengths as their own superpowers can make this easier.

A New Story to Grow Into
Through this work, children and teenagers can see themselves in a new light and write a new story about themselves. They come to understand that people are not friends with them by chance, that they have value, and that they bring something to others.
That shift matters for parents too: a child who feels seen is often a child who engages more readily with learning, whether through introducing reading at home or through learning English with less pressure. Small, repeated moments of recognition do more than one big talk.
It also helps to remember that a label can follow a child around. Before concluding that a child is difficult, it is worth asking whether the story around them needs rewriting, in the spirit of raising him well rather than blaming the child.

Outside Witnesses Who Strengthen the New Story
Once these elements are brought to the foreground, narrative practices bring in outside witnesses to reinforce the new story. These are people who matter in the child's life and who can confirm the qualities they appreciate, giving the emerging story more weight and durability.
For families, the practical lesson is to notice and name what a child does well, in front of others when possible, and to keep those moments linked together over time. That is how a fragile alternative story becomes the dominant one.
The same patience applies to inclusion: a child who is understood rather than judged, as in a child with autism, is a child better placed to learn and belong.
My hands-on take
I tried the friendship exercise at home after a rough school term, adapting it to a quiet evening rather than a classroom. I asked my child what they thought a close friend would say about them, and the first answers were short and doubtful. So I asked for one story, just one, of a time a friend had laughed or been glad to be with them. That was the opening.
What struck me was how much more weight the words carried when they came from a friend rather than from me. I stopped correcting the story and started collecting the small exceptions instead, writing them down so we could link them later. It did not fix everything overnight, but it changed the tone of our conversations, and my child began to offer examples without being asked.
Frequently asked questions
What are narrative practices in simple terms?
They are an approach based on the idea that people build identity through the stories they tell about themselves. The goal is to help someone notice exceptions to a problem story and build a richer, more hopeful alternative.
Does this replace professional support?
No. Narrative practices are a way of listening and relating that can complement other support. If a child is in real distress, speak with the school or a health professional.
Can parents use these ideas at home?
Yes. Listening without judging, asking about moments when things went well, and naming strengths in front of others are simple habits any parent can adopt.
Why focus on strengths rather than weaknesses?
Because a child who only hears about the problem builds a dominant story around failure. Naming real skills gives them material for a different story they can grow into.
