Sleep training methods explained: why they harm babies' health 2026

Damian Clay
Sleep training methods explained: why they harm babies' health
This page may contain affiliate links.

Sleep training methods promise a baby who settles alone and sleeps through the night, but the promise comes at a cost. Paediatric psychiatrist Rosa Jové, author of the book Dormir sans larmes, argues that these approaches share one common feature: leaving babies and young children to cry alone so they "learn" to sleep.

Her book walks through the mechanics of these programmes step by step and explains why she considers them harmful. Understanding the reasoning helps parents judge the advice they are given, rather than accepting it because it is repeated so often.



Quick takeaways

  • Broken sleep in the first year is normal, not a pathology to be cured.
  • No study shows short sleepers grow less than long sleepers.
  • Training programmes often frame babies as property rather than people.
  • Crying is communication about a need, not manipulation.
  • Responding to night calls does not mean you will never sleep again.
  • Gentle routines and realistic expectations beat rigid protocols.

How sleep training methods are sold to parents

Most programmes build on a manufactured problem. Jové points out that broken sleep in the first year is normal: nights are frequently interrupted by waking periods lasting from a minute to an hour. Between three and five years, sleep is better organised but still marked by trouble falling asleep, night waking, nightmares and fear of the dark.


Sponsored

She also dismantles the claim that short sleepers will pay for it in centimetres and kilos. Growth hormone is released during deep sleep, yet no study has shown a growth difference between children who sleep a lot and those who sleep little. What can affect growth is stress and trauma, since traumatised children stay on alert and their deep sleep may be cut short.

Parents who are not fed false hopes, she writes, are exactly the ones whose children's nights do not obsess them, even when they wake as often as everyone else's.

The cultural myth of the uninterrupted night

The uninterrupted night is not idealised in every culture as it is in ours. The same goes for getting a baby into a separate room as early as possible, to the point that co-sleeping is treated as a bad habit and many parents who practise it must justify themselves or hide it to have some peace.

This is where marketing does its work: convincing the majority that a baby who does not sleep has a serious pathology, and that without intervention the child's height, weight, school results and sleep habits will be disturbed forever. In reality, it is the training itself that creates stress and puts future health at risk. If bedtime has become a daily battle, it may help to read about child sleep before assuming something is wrong with your baby. And if hiccups in babies keep interrupting the evening, you will find simple explanations and remedies there too.


Sponsored

Baby crying alone in a cot at night

Comparing two approaches to night waking
Aspect Crying-based training Responsive approach
View of the baby Property of parents Full person with needs
Response to crying Delayed, timed Immediate, comforting
Main goal Child settles alone Child feels safe
Typical night Fewer calls, more distress More calls, less distress
Long-term message Calling brings no help Needs are heard

Step two: turning a baby into an object

Once parents are convinced their baby has a serious problem, the next step is to make the baby seem less than human, because otherwise how could a sensible person agree to cause distress on purpose? It is easier to act against someone once you strip them of personhood.

Jové criticises training manuals that describe babies not as full human beings with their own sensitivity and fundamental rights, but as their parents' property, as if belonging to the people who care for them justified ignoring their distress. This framing quietly removes the child's voice from the conversation. The same logic of listening to children rather than overriding them runs through debates on controversial parenting issues and on how much say a child should have in daily family life.

Step three: teaching parents to misread signals

What stops a mother from going to her child when he calls? Not the supposed pathology, since most mothers rush over when a child is ill, and not the idea that the child belongs to her, since in that case she picks him up without a second thought. For her to hold back, she must be convinced to misread the child's signals and made to feel tricked and rejected by her baby.


Sponsored

Several things make this easier. Adults forget what early childhood feels like, and they can be persuaded that babies are born manipulators. Adultism plays a part too: the belief that adults hold more rights than children and know better what is good for them. These blind spots make it hard to see that a crying baby is communicating a need, not running a strategy. The same principle applies to choosing pretend play toys that respect a child's developmental signals.

Parent sitting beside a baby's bed in a dim room

What babies are actually telling us

Night waking, crying and calling out are signals about basic needs: hunger, closeness, warmth, comfort or fear. Treating them as behaviour to be extinguished means the need goes unmet, and the child learns something different from what the programme promises. A baby left to cry does not learn to self-soothe; he learns that calling does not bring help.

For parents who want to respond without creating exhaustion, small practical adjustments often help more than any protocol. A predictable wind-down routine, a dim room and a calm adult presence do a lot of the work. If your baby wakes frequently to feed, night breastfeeding has practical guidance on handling those wake-ups without turning them into a battle, and toys for babies can help you build a calm, familiar bedtime environment.


Sponsored

Gentler alternatives that respect the child

Responding to a crying child at night is not the same as never sleeping. Many families find a middle path: shared sleep in some form, a parent who settles the child back down, and realistic expectations about what normal infant sleep looks like. The goal is a child who feels safe enough to let go, not a child who has given up asking.

Daytime matters too. Predictable meals, outdoor play and physical activity support better nights, and outdoor play is easy to encourage with outdoor toys for toddlers. Some children simply take a long time to unwind, which is worth exploring before assuming a training method is the answer. When a child is genuinely struggling, the priority is to look for the cause rather than to train the symptom away. A calm bedtime routine, such as dressing for Christmas or a familiar story, can help, and it is worth asking how to educate children without forcing the process.

Tired parent holding a baby during a night waking

Calm bedtime routine with a story before sleep


Sponsored

My hands-on take

I remember the first time someone handed me a printed schedule with minutes on it, and how quickly it turned my baby's crying into a maths problem. What helped me more was slowing down and watching: the same child who screamed at eight in the evening settled in ten minutes at half past eight with the light low and someone sitting nearby.

I am not going to pretend I never felt desperate at three in the morning. But once I stopped treating night waking as a fault to fix, the pressure lifted, and the nights got easier partly because I was calmer. If you take one thing from all this, let it be permission to trust what you see in your own child.

Frequently asked questions

Is any sleep training method acceptable?

The core criticism concerns methods that leave a child to cry alone for increasing periods. Approaches built on presence, comfort and gradual change sit differently, because the child is not left without an answer.

Will my baby ever sleep through the night?

Most children do, in their own time, as sleep matures. Jové's point is that this natural development happens without intervention, provided it is not disrupted.


Sponsored

Does co-sleeping create bad habits?

The idea that it does is cultural rather than scientific. Many families share sleep safely and find it reduces night stress for everyone.

What if I am exhausted and need help?

Wanting rest is legitimate. Look for support that keeps you present with your child, such as sharing nights with a partner, rather than a protocol that removes you from the room.


Sponsored

Author

Damian Clay

Damian is a lifelong LEGO building blocks enthusiast, and certified STEM educator with decades of experience in creative building and design. As the founder of BrickMasters Blog, he shares expert reviews, innovative building techniques, and educational insights trusted by hobbyists and educators alike. James’s work has been featured in leading toy publications, making him a respected voice in the building blocks community.

Instagram

CADA BRICKS® Bestseller ⭐

View all
Cada 4739PCS Technisches Ferrari City Rennwagen Hypercar Modell Bausteine Sportwagen Fahrzeug Bausteine Spielzeug Kinder Geschenke

Cada 4739PCS Technisches Ferrari City Rennwagen Hypercar Modell Bausteine Sportwagen Fahrzeug Bausteine Spielzeug Kinder Geschenke

Cada 4739PCS Technisches Ferrari City Rennwagen Hypercar Modell Bausteine Sportwagen Fahrzeug Bausteine Spielzeug Kinder Geschenke

CHF 198.07
Cada 1:24 Technisches Drift-Rennwagen C42 Sportwagen Modellbausteine Stadt Ausdauer-Sportwagen Bausteinspielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada 1:24 Technisches Drift-Rennwagen C42 Sportwagen Modellbausteine Stadt Ausdauer-Sportwagen Bausteinspielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada 1:24 Technisches Drift-Rennwagen C42 Sportwagen Modellbausteine Stadt Ausdauer-Sportwagen Bausteinspielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

CHF 19.03
Cada 422 Stück Stadt Retro Kombination Sicherer Bausteine Das Geheimnis des sicheren Experimentierens Bildungsspielsteine Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

Cada 422 Stück Stadt Retro Kombination Sicherer Bausteine Das Geheimnis des sicheren Experimentierens Bildungsspielsteine Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

Cada 422 Stück Stadt Retro Kombination Sicherer Bausteine Das Geheimnis des sicheren Experimentierens Bildungsspielsteine Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

CHF 48.59
Cada 3935 Stück Technisches Gepanzertes SUV Auto Buggy LKW Pickup Bausteine Stadt Geländewagen Fernsteuerungsauto Bausteinspielzeug Geschenke

Cada 3935 Stück Technisches Gepanzertes SUV Auto Buggy LKW Pickup Bausteine Stadt Geländewagen Fernsteuerungsauto Bausteinspielzeug Geschenke

Cada 3935 Stück Technisches Gepanzertes SUV Auto Buggy LKW Pickup Bausteine Stadt Geländewagen Fernsteuerungsauto Bausteinspielzeug Geschenke

CHF 247.30
Cada 865 Stück Stadt Solar System Erde und Sonne Uhr Bausteine Wissenschaftliches Experiment Bildungsbausteine Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

Cada 865 Stück Stadt Solar System Erde und Sonne Uhr Bausteine Wissenschaftliches Experiment Bildungsbausteine Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

Cada 865 Stück Stadt Solar System Erde und Sonne Uhr Bausteine Wissenschaftliches Experiment Bildungsbausteine Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

CHF 57.49
Cada 4WD Geländewagen Fernsteuerbares Auto Bausteine Stadt Rennwagen RC Buggy Lastwagen SUV Pickup Bausteinspielzeug für Jungen

Cada 4WD Geländewagen Fernsteuerbares Auto Bausteine Stadt Rennwagen RC Buggy Lastwagen SUV Pickup Bausteinspielzeug für Jungen

Cada 4WD Geländewagen Fernsteuerbares Auto Bausteine Stadt Rennwagen RC Buggy Lastwagen SUV Pickup Bausteinspielzeug für Jungen

CHF 84.69
Cada 1655 Stück 1:10 Neu 2024 RC Klassisches Deutschland 2019 Sportwagen LED Bausteine Stadt Fernsteuerungs-Rennwagen Bausteinspielzeug für Jungen

Cada 1655 Stück 1:10 Neu 2024 RC Klassisches Deutschland 2019 Sportwagen LED Bausteine Stadt Fernsteuerungs-Rennwagen Bausteinspielzeug für Jungen

Cada 1655 Stück 1:10 Neu 2024 RC Klassisches Deutschland 2019 Sportwagen LED Bausteine Stadt Fernsteuerungs-Rennwagen Bausteinspielzeug für Jungen

CHF 120.67
Cada 325 Stück Stadt Technisches RC Drift Rennwagen Bausteine DIY Toyota AE86 Sportwagen Bausteine Geschenke Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada 325 Stück Stadt Technisches RC Drift Rennwagen Bausteine DIY Toyota AE86 Sportwagen Bausteine Geschenke Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada 325 Stück Stadt Technisches RC Drift Rennwagen Bausteine DIY Toyota AE86 Sportwagen Bausteine Geschenke Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

CHF 53.53
Cada 1:20 328 Stück Stadt Technologisches RC Rennwagen App Bausteine Fernsteuerung Schnelles Fahrzeug Baustein Spielzeug Feiertagsgeschenke

Cada 1:20 328 Stück Stadt Technologisches RC Rennwagen App Bausteine Fernsteuerung Schnelles Fahrzeug Baustein Spielzeug Feiertagsgeschenke

Cada 1:20 328 Stück Stadt Technologisches RC Rennwagen App Bausteine Fernsteuerung Schnelles Fahrzeug Baustein Spielzeug Feiertagsgeschenke

CHF 43.30
Cada City ferngesteuertes Rennwagen kompatibel mit MOC Bausteinen RC Supersportwagen Bausteine Kinder Jungen Geschenke Spielzeug

Cada City ferngesteuertes Rennwagen kompatibel mit MOC Bausteinen RC Supersportwagen Bausteine Kinder Jungen Geschenke Spielzeug

Cada City ferngesteuertes Rennwagen kompatibel mit MOC Bausteinen RC Supersportwagen Bausteine Kinder Jungen Geschenke Spielzeug

CHF 28.56
Cada LED Stadt Japanischer Stil Lebensmittelgeschäft Haus Bausteine Doppeldecker Duplex Architektur Bausteine Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada LED Stadt Japanischer Stil Lebensmittelgeschäft Haus Bausteine Doppeldecker Duplex Architektur Bausteine Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada LED Stadt Japanischer Stil Lebensmittelgeschäft Haus Bausteine Doppeldecker Duplex Architektur Bausteine Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

CHF 72.79
Cada City Fernsteuerbares Ingenieurfahrzeug LKW Kran Bausteine MOC RC Auto Bausteine DIY Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada City Fernsteuerbares Ingenieurfahrzeug LKW Kran Bausteine MOC RC Auto Bausteine DIY Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada City Fernsteuerbares Ingenieurfahrzeug LKW Kran Bausteine MOC RC Auto Bausteine DIY Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

CHF 208.23
Cada Anime Initial D Champion Fahrzeug Bausteine Kompatibel mit City Street View Japanischer Parkplatz Baustein Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

Cada Anime Initial D Champion Fahrzeug Bausteine Kompatibel mit City Street View Japanischer Parkplatz Baustein Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

Cada Anime Initial D Champion Fahrzeug Bausteine Kompatibel mit City Street View Japanischer Parkplatz Baustein Spielzeug Jungen Geschenke

CHF 18.90
Cada LED Stadt Japanischer Stil Kantinenhaus Architektur Bausteine Spätnachtskantine Figuren Bausteinspielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada LED Stadt Japanischer Stil Kantinenhaus Architektur Bausteine Spätnachtskantine Figuren Bausteinspielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Cada LED Stadt Japanischer Stil Kantinenhaus Architektur Bausteine Spätnachtskantine Figuren Bausteinspielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

CHF 86.41
Mit Verpackung BOX LED Stadt Japanisches Teehaus Architektur Bausteine Freunde Laden Figuren Bausteine Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Mit Verpackung BOX LED Stadt Japanisches Teehaus Architektur Bausteine Freunde Laden Figuren Bausteine Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

Mit Verpackung BOX LED Stadt Japanisches Teehaus Architektur Bausteine Freunde Laden Figuren Bausteine Spielzeug für Kinder Geschenke

CHF 94.88

Premium Building Blocks

Building Blocks Toy™ is known for mechanically accurate, highly detailed designs and construction sets viewed as the best LEGO alternatives. From working gearboxes to articulated suspension systems, our top kits feature real-world engineering scaled down to hands-on form.

Free Express World Delivery

We offer Free and fast shipping worldwide, with a worry-free money-back guarantee. We deliver the best building blocks on the market—built to last, tested for safety, and designed for builders of all ages.

24/7 Builder Support

We're dedicated to your satisfaction. Our team of specialists is available 24/7 to answer your questions, and help you choose the best building blocks for your needs.