Corporal punishment of children remains one of the most heated topics in parenting, and it is easy to see why: most adults were raised with it and were told it was for their own good. That makes any calm conversation feel like a personal accusation.
This article looks at why resistance to abolition is so strong, what corporal punishment does to the adult psyche, and what parents can actually do to stop reproducing a violent education. The aim is not to shame anyone, but to make the subject discussable.
Quick takeaways
- Resistance to abolition is cultural, not evidence-based: most adults were smacked and told it was for their good.
- Corporal punishment affects adult life through fear, emotional confusion and difficulty speaking up.
- Attachment suffers most: children may come to associate love with violence.
- Empathy and immunity can both weaken when stress from hitting repeats.
- Breaking the cycle starts with conscious recognition that smacking caused harm.
- Help exists, and educational violence is not inevitable.
Why Is There So Much Resistance to Abolishing Corporal Punishment?
Adults who say a good smack never hurt anyone often do not feel the psychological pain those punishments inflicted on them. There is a great deal of unconsciousness around smacking, because most of the planet received it and was led to believe corporal punishment was for its own good. Questioning it means questioning one's own parents.
The writer Olivier Maurel observed that in countries where beating with sticks is still practised, adults reason in exactly the same way: "if my parents hadn't beaten me, I would have turned out badly." Our thinking is shaped less by the supposed harmlessness of corporal punishment than by culture, by having been habituated to it from early childhood by the people we loved most.
Why the Debate Turns Emotional
Because the argument is never really about a stranger's childhood. It is about our own, and about the parents we still love. That is why a discussion about stubborn children or discipline can suddenly feel like a verdict on a whole family history.
What Are the Risks to the Adult Psyche?
The consequences described by psychotherapist Brigitte Oriol are wide-ranging. They include a state of fear in certain situations, caused by traumatic memory, and a state of emotional and affective confusion: the lesson that it is acceptable to hurt people you are supposed to love, that good can be done in the name of harm, that the strongest wins and that violence is justified because it resolves conflict.
Other effects include a reduced capacity to speak in public, such as simply asking for directions, and a risk of replicating a violent education through mirror neurons. Attachment is also disturbed: the worst danger for a baby is abandonment, so evolution built reactions to attract a parent's attention, like crying, smiling and outstretched arms. Violence disrupts that bond, and some children come to associate love with violence, carrying it into adult relationships.
Empathy, Immunity and the Developing Brain
Empathy, the basis of social relationships and morality, can decline: someone who had to cut off their emotions to stop suffering finds it harder to feel the suffering of others. The immune system weakens too, because a child who is hit registers an aggression and reacts with stress, secreting cortisol to prepare for fight or flight. When stress repeats, the body shuts down non-essential functions such as digestion, and this constant switching weakens immunity, which explains why frequently hit children fall ill more often.
Catherine Gueguen, in her book Pour une enfance heureuse, adds a higher risk of depression, delayed development of certain neural circuits in the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus, aggressive behaviour, mood disorders, and insensitivity or hardness. Parents noticing early signs of distress may find it useful to learn to recognise traumatic symptoms rather than dismiss them. Small everyday gestures, such as helping children grow strong, can also support their recovery.

| Area affected | What may happen | Supportive response |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional memory | Fear in certain situations | Name triggers, seek safe context |
| Attachment | Love confused with violence | Consistent, predictable care |
| Empathy | Difficulty feeling others' pain | Practise naming feelings |
| Immune system | More frequent illness | Reduce stress, restore routines |
| Parenting style | Automatic repetition | Reflect, repair, ask for help |
How Can Parents Stop Inflicting Corporal Punishment?
Someone who received smacks can avoid reproducing a violent education on one condition: having become conscious that those smacks did them harm. That path is necessarily the fruit of deliberate reflection, not of good intentions alone.
Forgiving a parent who smacked us requires that the parent acknowledge the harm done and admit they were so unequipped that they had no other means than to hurt their child. This first step opens the way to compassion for the former child we have become, and allows us to care for our inner child.
Everyday Alternatives to the Smack
In the moment of tension, the practical move is to step back before reacting: name the feeling, lower your voice, and deal with the behaviour once the storm has passed. Parents who want concrete scripts can find free guidance on calming home routines and simple ways to respond without raising a hand.
How Do You Break the Circle of Educational Violence?
Some parents are terrified by the violence inside them and by what they inflict on their children. When you sense that corporal punishment is destructive but feel as though you are on automatic pilot, you need help to step out of the circle of educational violence.
A safe and caring context is required to dare to speak about it, and it is treatable. The circle can be broken if we dare to look at what was done to us in childhood. Being a parent is complex, but educational violence is not inevitable.
Resources and Support
Useful starting points include a free document on what to do instead of smacking, and material that helps parents understand and move beyond educational violence. Building a support network matters as much as reading: a trusted friend, a parenting group or a professional can hold the conversation when it feels too heavy alone. Busy parents can also turn to apps for busy parents to find support in the moments they have.
Small daily habits help too. Naming emotions, repairing after a rupture and keeping routines predictable all reduce the moments where shouting or hitting once felt normal. Parents who want to build a warmer atmosphere at home often begin with shared activities, from wooden playhouse projects to cooking together, because connection lowers tension on both sides. Movement helps as well, and it is worth knowing when children can dance so shared play becomes part of the routine.

What Does a Calmer, Non-Violent Education Look Like in Practice?
A non-violent education is not permissive. It sets limits clearly, holds them calmly and separates the child's behaviour from the child's worth. The message a child needs is: I disapprove of what you did, and I will never stop protecting you.
That message is built through repetition, not perfection. Repairing after a difficult moment, explaining what will happen next and acknowledging your own mistakes all teach children that conflict can be resolved without fear. Parents looking for gentle ways to spend time together can explore sensory play benefits or educational toys for toddlers that keep hands busy and moods steady.
Over time, the goal is a household where discipline means guidance rather than punishment, and where children learn limits from adults who remain predictable and kind.

My hands-on take
I remember the first time my child pushed me to the edge of my patience and I felt my hand rise almost on its own. What stopped me was not a technique but a memory: the sting of a smack I received as a child and the confusion that followed, the sense that the person I loved most had chosen to hurt me. I put my hand down and walked to the kitchen for a glass of water.
Since then, I have tried to treat those moments as information rather than failure. I apologise when I raise my voice, I explain what happens next, and I keep the limits firm without the fear. It is not always graceful, but it is a choice I make again each day, and it gets a little easier.
Frequently asked questions
Is corporal punishment still common?
Yes, it remains widespread globally, and many adults were raised with it. That shared history is precisely why the topic feels so personal and why calm discussion is difficult.
Does being smacked as a child mean I will smack my own children?
Not necessarily. Repetition is a risk, not a destiny, and it can be interrupted through conscious reflection on the harm received and support in moments of tension.
What can I do in the moment when I feel like hitting?
Step away briefly, breathe, and address the behaviour once you are calm. Repairing afterwards teaches children that conflict can be handled without fear.
Where can parents find help?
Free guides on alternatives to smacking, parenting groups and professionals all offer a safe context to talk. The key is not to stay alone with the feeling of being out of control.
