Homework is useless before middle school, argues a former primary teacher who now regrets the volume she assigned. Jessica Smock, a doctor in education science and mother of two, explains that her old beliefs were driven by fear: fear of pupil failure, fear of disappointing parents, fear of international rankings.
Research she later read found no causal link between the amount of homework and academic performance in primary school. Instead, homework tends to damage children's attitude to school, strain family relationships and steal time from play.
This article looks at what children could be doing instead, and what French regulations say about written work at home.
Quick takeaways
- No study links homework volume to better results in primary school
- Homework raises stress, fatigue and family conflict
- Free play, chores, music and boredom are real learning
- French law bans written homework in primary school since 1956
- Oral work and lessons to learn remain permitted
- Parents can politely decline written homework
Why homework fails younger children
No study has ever established a causal link between the volume of homework set and the academic results of primary school pupils. What research does show is less flattering: homework tends to worsen children's attitude towards teachers and school in general, bringing fear, stress, a lack of confidence and fatigue.
It also damages family life. Homework becomes a source of conflict, punishment and misunderstanding between parents and children, and it takes time away from activities that genuinely support motor, cognitive and emotional development, such as free play and outdoor games.
Beliefs driven by fear
Many teachers set homework because they are afraid of failing their pupils or of disappointing parents, not because the evidence supports it. Recognising that pressure is the first step towards giving children back their afternoons, whether that means more outdoor toys or simply an empty schedule.
What children could do instead
The alternative list is long and deliberately ordinary. Children could skip rope or bounce on a trampoline, talk with the family, sleep, read freely for pleasure, do puzzles, play outside, dig holes in the sand with friends, or help prepare dinner and contribute to household tasks.
They could care for animals, walk the dog, play an instrument, listen to classical music, draw, paint, glue, run science experiments, visit grandparents, dress up, roughhouse, invent stories, be bored, meditate, build with construction toys, learn to sew or knit, ride a bike, take photos, play cooperative games with children of all ages, garden or dance. For quieter moments, there are beautiful sea stories to share together.
School learning is only one form of learning. Homework nibbles at the time available for social, emotional and motor learning, and the point is to watch how much of a child's day is structured, adult-imposed, still, indoor and stressful. Families who later decide to part with unused sets can learn where to sell Lego sets.

| Activity | What it builds | Adult role |
|---|---|---|
| Written worksheets | Little measurable gain before middle school | Sets and corrects |
| Free play outdoors | Motor skills, social negotiation | Steps back |
| Helping with dinner | Responsibility, family belonging | Invites and guides |
| Reading for pleasure | Vocabulary, motivation | Offers books |
| Learning a lesson orally | Memory, autonomy | Listens and quizzes |
The case for boredom and free play
Boredom is on the list for a reason. Unstructured time is where children learn to invent, negotiate and manage their own attention, and a house with a few open-ended options makes that easier than a house full of screens.
Free play sits at the heart of development, and so does movement outdoors. If you want to build a play-friendly home, start with a small stock of versatile toys and a shelf of illustrated books rather than a pile of worksheets. A children's apps collection can help too, provided it stays a small part of the day.
Older children need this less obviously but no less truly; respecting a teenager's space and their free time matters just as much as filling a younger child's afternoon with play.
What French law says about written homework
France has been unusually clear on this point. A circular dated 29 December 1956, applying a decree of 23 November 1956, ordered the suppression of homework: no written work, obligatory or optional, was to be demanded of pupils outside class, and inspectors were asked to enforce it strictly.
A circular of 6 September 1994 repeated the ban, limiting work at home to oral work or lessons to learn. A 2002 decree set out the essential functions of personal work: fixing certain learning and memorising, liaison with families, and developing autonomy, responsibility and a sense of organisation. For parents seeking support, there are helpful motherhood blogs worth reading.
Learning how to learn
The method matters more than the volume. Pupils should be taught in class how to learn a lesson, a poem or a multiplication table, and how to prepare a presentation or carry out research. The rule is that school must teach children to manage without school, first with heavy guidance and then gradually alone, much like the patience behind collecting rarest Lego sets.

What parents can actually do
After half a century of regulatory change, and with social and family inequalities inevitably shaping home support, the position is established: written homework is strictly forbidden in primary school, though teachers may give oral work and lessons to learn.
In practice, a primary teacher can ask for oral work such as reading or research, and for lessons to be learned at home. Nothing written, obligatory or optional, may be required outside class.
As a parent, you can decline to have your child complete written homework, even if that feels awkward. It helps to talk to the teacher calmly, explain the legal position and ask what oral work is expected. Reading together, cooking, a board game or a outdoor toys afternoon all count as legitimate learning. If your child is drawn to building sets, a few LEGO sets can absorb an entire evening of quiet, self-directed play. Staying informed also helps, as shown by news about the vaccination schedule.

My hands-on take
I tried the worksheet routine for a few months with my eldest and it mostly produced tears and a resentful parent. When we dropped it and replaced the slot with a walk, a puzzle or cooking, evenings changed completely and so did the mood at breakfast.
What helped most was talking to the teacher rather than quietly opting out. We asked what oral work was expected, kept a short reading habit, and let the rest of the afternoon stay empty. My advice is to protect the empty space first and let the activities fill it themselves.
Frequently asked questions
Is homework really useless in primary school?
Research has not found a causal link between homework volume and academic performance before middle school. It has found negative effects on attitude, stress and family life.
Is homework illegal in France?
Written homework, obligatory or optional, is banned outside class in primary school under a 1956 circular, confirmed in 1994. Teachers may still give oral work and lessons to learn.
Can I refuse homework for my child?
You can decline written homework and discuss it with the teacher. Ask instead what oral work or lessons are expected, so your child stays involved.
Won't my child fall behind without homework?
Consolidation happens in class, where the teacher can guide it. Reading, conversation and play support learning without the conflict homework often creates.
